Settings

The page will reload to apply your changes.
Theme

ASCII Art Font

ASCII Art Menu

Original Usenet message from alt.ascii-art, 31 Mar 1999.
Re: FAQs: What to do?

Re: FAQs: What to do?

Ilmari Karonen wrote:
> Veronica Karlsson wrote:
> : I said that each person should be able to choose how they want to format
> : their copy. I.e. what colours to use, what kind of file to use, if they
> : want to use <p> or <pre> for ordinairy text, if they want to use CSS,
> : etc. It's all just looks. What matters is the content.
> 
> I agree with that if and only if sufficiently narrow limits are placed on
> what changes can be made. I've seen too many sites where the style itself
> - even if entirely approprite for the main content and reader profile of
> said site - makes reading a FAQ a pain.

I think that's just a case of some people having talent/skill for doing
things that other people can read and some people not having that
talent/skill. In some cases it's a sign of somebody trying to hard to
make something that "looks professional" and in some cases it's a sign
of somebody _learning_ and making some mistakes (i.e. some will learn,
some will not). Also, different people have different taste. Some people
find it difficult to read certain colour combinations or small text.
Having the FAQ presented in different ways on different sites would make
it potentially more readable, IMO.

> Think dark green 7pt "fancy" font on black starfield background, width
> limited to 400 pixels, enclosed in a table in order to top it all with a
> graphically intensive navigation column.

*brrr!*

> Maybe none of us would do that to the FAQ, but maybe someone would.
> Besides, there are several other points:
> 
>  * A FAQ file should above all be as readable as possible. The reader's
>    default setting usually get closer to that than anything the page
>    designer can provide. Not everyone wants to override author styles even
>    if they do prefer their FAQs simple and legible.

Mhmm... Define "as readable as possible"!

I had a LONG discussion about this with a graphic designer once.

My argument: Don't change fonts! Those readers who care will have set
their browsers to use a font that is "optimal" for them, in some way.
Those who don't care - DON'T CARE!

Her argument: Always use font X! Studies made by scientific institutes Y
and Z have shown that fonts of the same type as X is more readable than
other fonts, and font X is our company standard.

My argument: Don't set a fixed width on a web page! Let the HTML "flow"!
Let it be flexible and adapt to the situation! It is up to each reader
to set his or her browser so that it shows text in a readable way.

Her argument: Always set a fixed width on a web page! Studies made by
scientific institutes Y and Z have shown that text should have a certain
amount of words on each line to be more readable. Given that you use
font X and font size Q you know how wide the text is and can calculate a
suitable width for the document.

Who is right? Who is wrong? We both had good, solid arguments for our
different ways of doing things. Before we can have any discussion about
how to write this to be "as readable as possible" we must define what we
mean by that, OR we could each do it our own way.

For example, I look at llizard's use of <FONT> as Outdated, she sees my
use of CSS as Bad. There is no way you're going to get us both to agree
on ONE format!

>  * If the FAQs are updated anywhere near frequently, the HTML for each
>    mirror should be identical. Of course, a LINK element could be used to
>    add site-specific styles, but this still imposes limits in any case.

The HTML of the main body of content, yes. But if I find something like:

<a name="figlet"></a>
<h3>What is Figlet?</h3>

I WILL change that to:

<h3><a name="figlet">What is Figlet?</a></h3>

(or if I find a <font> tag in there that too will get snipped out...)

Also, I see a typical HTML document as consisting of three parts:

 +-------------+
 | top part    |
 +-------------+
 +-------------+
 | middle part |
 | (content)   |
 |             |
 +-------------+
 +-------------+
 | end part    |
 +-------------+

OK, on some sites they have the "top part" in a box down along the left
side of the page, but the main idea is still the same.

What I think the FAQ people should do is provide the middle part, the
content, and let each person put whatever top and end part on as they
like.

Here's an example of what I mean:

http://www.ludd.luth.se/~vk/pics/temp/example.html

The top part consists of the usual <head> code, plus a logo and a black
line. The middle part consists of the words "Example Page, Content goes
here". The end part consists of another black line and some "navigation"
links.

>  * Relating to the previous point, IMHO the whole point of mirroring is
>    that the mirrors should be identical, not varying interpretations of
>    the base document. The way I see it, if the author of the original page
>    wants BODY { text-color: green; } then green text it shall be, but not
>    otherwise.

If the author insists on any specific colours, etc, I will not be part
of this "mirroring" business.

>  * Besides, people expect informational decuments to be simple and without
>    distractions.

I can agree with that.

>    Just because I can read the FAQ just as easily in purple
>    text doesn't mean that the unexpected color change wouln't be an
>    incovenience if I was browsing around for info on, say, configuring OE4
>    to show ascii art properly.

THAT argument belongs in the "To CSS or not to CSS?" debate.

> The key here is relevancy. I'd have no problems with a big animated GIF if
> it was useful for illustrating a particular answer. But such decisions are
> up to the FAQ author, not to the mirror providers.

If somebody wants to be stupid an put an animated background on their
page, I won't try to stop them. If they try to put that same animated
background on MY page, then I'd rather not have anything to do with
them. Again, you will not be able to find as much as one "look", not
even one colour combination, that everybody here can agree with.

> I'm not saying some allowances couldn't be made. For example a
> site-specific navigation bar at the bottom shouldn't be too bad, though
> just a simple link might suffice. I suppose we'll have to allow GeoGuides
> too.. :-(
> 

Mmmm...  :(

> Anyway, that's just my view. If those with the power (the FAQ author(s))
> decide that mirrors may use their own styles, then I won't complain. But
> my copy (if I'm allowed one, that is) will still be faithful to the
> original, and I hope just for the readers' sake that the central mirror
> list will mark mirrors as either original or modified.

If you want to keep Your copy identical to the original, that should be
your choice, but don't try to force that same choice on the rest of us.


If somebody decides to change the wording in the _content_ of one of the
documents however...   >:-(

-- 
    (,         http://www.ludd.luth.se/~vk/cgi/asciichat/
    /|__--__                       .                        __--__
    |\ '__                        /|\                        _{ _ 
    `.' / `.,_ _________           |           _________ _,.' (/ `.
    /  ||``._.'             ASCII ART CHAT!             `---'|:||,/
  .'   /|                                                   /|:| \
.'    /\ \         __   __                _                 `/|'\'
 ` `,/ /`,\        \ \ / /__ _ _ ___ _ _ (_)__ __ _         /,'\ \
   .'.'  /|         \ V / -_) '_/ _ \ ' \| / _/ _` |        |\  `.`.
 ,' /   / |          \_/\___|_| \___/_||_|_\__\__,_|        | \   \ `,
- `- -- `-'- -ejm-------------------------------------VK-- -`-' -- -' -

Original message headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit
X-Google-Thread: f996b,8b445698b5d16d54
X-Google-Attributes: gidf996b,public
From: Veronica Karlsson <aci...@earthling.net>
Subject: Re: FAQs: What to do?
Date: 1999/03/31
Message-ID: <370...@earthling.net>
X-Deja-AN: 460951969
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
References: <36f...@news.vossnet.net> <36F...@on.spammer> <SfPL2.45$H5....@news3.ispnews.com> <36F...@on.spammer> <7dr0o4$i67$1...@tron.sci.fi>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Organization: University of Lulea, Sweden
Mime-Version: 1.0
Newsgroups: alt.ascii-art
About this message. This message was posted publicly to the newsgroup alt.ascii-art in 1999 and is mirrored here unchanged as part of the Historic Archives – only email addresses are masked. The artwork and text belong to their original authors: if you copy a piece, keep the artist's initials or signature intact and credit them where you can. Are you the author? Contact us to get your posts attributed, connected to your artist profile, or removed.

Report this message

Help us keep the archive clean and accurate. Reports are reviewed by a person – nothing is changed automatically.

Help classify this post