Settings

The page will reload to apply your changes.
Theme

ASCII Art Font

ASCII Art Menu

Original Usenet message from alt.ascii-art, 13 Feb 1995.
Talk: Ripping off Artwork: A discussion

Talk: Ripping off Artwork: A discussion

dca...@casbah.acns.nwu.edu (Daniel Au) writes:
(munch)

>Now this is just to get the opinions of others on this newsgroup, no flames
>intended (please don't be offended Steve).  Now, there's a fine line between
>ripping off another's artwork and diddling it into something else.  Case in
>point, the above statement about working on the far out boneman that was
>posted (thanks for the compliment by the way).  The picture was first made and
>posted by me.  A second party, in this case Mr. Crisp, goes and diddles with
>it and adds a few changes (see article 20688 for reference.) 

>Now looking at the artwork, there is now no longer a mention that I am the
>artist, which was there originally (see article 20547 for full picture):

>>         #    || ||  	  	      __
>>         #    || ||           	      ||
>>         #    () ()		|~~~~~~~~~~~~~
>>         #    || || 		|  by DCAU!  | 
>>         #    || ||		|____________|
>>         #    o   o   	              ||
>>         #  /||' '||\       -__---_-_||_-__--_---  


>And thus the original creator was lost.  Now Steve did a nice diddle of the
>skeleton and added his own stake in the ground.  Who is the artist now? 

>Personally, I would have liked my name retained on the diddle (as was TL
>Hesman's name was kept in the evolution of the lovebirds, for those of you who
>keep up with the posts).  I know in the real world this won't always happen
>because people don't want to spoil 'their' artwork with someone elses name,
>but it would be nice and it is courteous.

I agree with most of dcau's posting, but here's another just for the
hell of it...

At a international congress of folk art in the twenties (or thereabouts), 
with famous folk song collectors like Cecil Sharpe, there were debates as 
to (a) whether folk art could be defined, and (b) to whom the intellectual
rights of a song (etc) belonged.

The opinion that was accepted then, and has been widely held since runs
roughly as follows.  Consider (A) writes a song; (B) interprets it his was,
(C) listening to (B) makes a dance tune out of it; (D) hears (C)'s version
and plays it on different instruments at ceidilhs, with a set of other tunes, 
(E) hears it and fits different words to the tune, incorporating a bit of 
the other melodies in the set, and so on all the way to (Z).  Now (Z)'s tune
bears no resemblance to (A) and all of (A)-(Z) have had some part in the 
creation of the final thing.  Though (A) may have kicked the whole process
off, there is no identifiable author any longer.  Folk art is art when this
sort of thing happens.  The works belong to everyone and to no-one.

This does not mean that folk artists do not consider they have been ripped 
off from time to time.  They can go on about it something beastly like
any other species of human being.  However the trend is still there.

ASCII art seems to go through this process in minature.  Ripping off a whole
image because of a tiny diddle is not OK any more than copying Beethoven's
9th and diddling a few notes.  However to insist on rigorously crediting
all contributors will inhibit the growth of multiply diddled 'folk art'
images.

Perhaps you can drop the inital author's name if you feel you have put a
lot onto the picture, but surely the real no-no is to put your name on
instead!

I dunno. I rather like seeing something of mine being used by someone else.
Cheers.

 adBBba. Ba.   A             ~VgooodB   ,B B.    B       
  b  ,B" _ S"b B.Bb .dBb .B dBBB.   B.aP"  _"B. JB.aPb   
  BaP"  .B B .JB? B B. B.BBV B  B   BK.    B  BP'BCaP'   
  B `YaaP' VBP B  B? VB?' B  `bd'   B "YaaBP  B  B "Vbaa 








--
Richard Kirk                      01483-448869 (phone)  01483-448845 (fax)
Canon Research Europe Ltd,                              ra...@canon.co.uk

Original message headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit
X-Google-Thread: f996b,c8cd4c4d381bbbe8
X-Google-Attributes: gidf996b,public
X-Google-Thread: fbb9d,327a38845773d68e
X-Google-Attributes: gidfbb9d,public
X-Google-ArrivalTime: 1995-02-13 00:48:37 PST
Path: nntp.gmd.de!newsserver.jvnc.net!howland.reston.ans.net!news.sprintlink.net!sashimi.wwa.com!not-for-mail
From: ra...@canon.co.uk (Richard Kirk)
Newsgroups: alt.ascii-art,rec.arts.ascii
Subject: Talk: Ripping off Artwork: A discussion
Date: 13 Feb 1995 02:48:37 -0600
Organization: Canon Research Centre Europe Ltd
Lines: 87
Sender: bob...@gagme.wwa.com
Approved: bob...@wwa.com
Message-ID: <3hn6d5$8q...@gagme.wwa.com>
References: <cpl...@rncb.demon.co.uk> <199...@dcs.warwick.ac.uk> <35...@acorn.win-uk.net> <3hgv37$fm...@gagme.wwa.com>
NNTP-Posting-Host: gagme.wwa.com
Xref: nntp.gmd.de alt.ascii-art:19986 rec.arts.ascii:3883
About this message. This message was posted publicly to the newsgroup alt.ascii-art in 1995 and is mirrored here unchanged as part of the Historic Archives – only email addresses are masked. The artwork and text belong to their original authors: if you copy a piece, keep the artist's initials or signature intact and credit them where you can. Are you the author? Contact us to get your posts attributed, connected to your artist profile, or removed.

Report this message

Help us keep the archive clean and accurate. Reports are reviewed by a person – nothing is changed automatically.

Help classify this post