Settings

The page will reload to apply your changes.
Theme

ASCII Art Font

ASCII Art Menu

Original Usenet message from alt.ascii-art, 23 May 1994.
VOTING: rec.arts.ascii (MODERATED)

VOTING: rec.arts.ascii (MODERATED)

[ This posting is not in the usual format due to a hardware failure
destroying   the earlier postings so that a normal reply cannot be made ]

In reply to the posting by Dwayne Jarvis, ( actually Rowan Crawford, ROW )
who wrote: 


First let me say that I am pleased you have entered the public 
debate and regret that you did not do so much earlier when the RFD 
( Request for Discussion ) was taking place and before this late 
stage in the voting proceedings.


THE BIG APPEAL OF ALT.ASCII-ART:

ROW> What is the big appeal of a.a-a?


- Freedom for all comers.

- Lots of pictures.

- Lots of requests :-)

- Great enjoyment for many users ( regrettably not all ).

- The potential to become one of the top ten groups. 

  An estimated 86,000 readers and a site propagation level of 44% in 
  just a few months of the group's formation is remarkable for any 
  group - _and_ a group not regarded as a "proper" newsgroup 
  according to the proponents of rec.arts.ascii ( MODERATED ).
  The results to date speak for themselves.  



REQUESTS, REQUESTS, REQUESTS: Battle cry of the moderationists.


CD> Do you seriously believe that this an acceptable response to 
CD> _any_ reader's request for one picture ?  Not only is it 
CD> unfriendly, it is inappropriate, frustrating and bordering on the 
CD> ridiculous.

> It's actually a very standardized way to deal with such things as FAQs.  
> Many groups do this because it's efficiant.  

Many groups ?  Name them.

Standardized ?  Which standard is that then ?


> Wo wo wo.  etc....

Sounds like you're calling in the horses. We say " Git in behind ! " 
this side of the Tasman. :-)        


> requests. Am I clear on what I mean there?  

Sure. You're meaning is clear enough. It is your understanding of the 
true nature of requests that is flawed. 

Frankly, I despair of ever being able to get this message across to 
the anti-request brigade. Here we go for the umpteenth time:

To the requester each and every request is _new_ and quite normal. 

Popular subjects are bound to be requested frequently but by 
_ENTIRELY DIFFERENT PEOPLE_ who simply have not seen all the other 
requests.  

Newcomers are arriving in the group continuously and at a great rate.


> Requests were never what a.a-a were about originally. 

There were very few people reading the group originally.


> It's only lately that they have - quite literally - taken over the 
>  group.  

I consider that nonsense - I've been reading this group since about 
late September 1993 - as soon as I heard about it - and I simply do 
not agree with you - so there !  :-) :-)


> They dont fit into the reason why a.a-a was created in the first 
> place, although of course they have some relevance.  

Well you had better post the alt.ascii-art Charter because I am sure 
most of us haven't seen it - so how can we assess the validity of 
your statements ?

Perhaps it would help if the Charter appeared continuously in this 
newsgroup for all to see.


> There's no doubting that requests have killed original art here 
> (anyone dissagree?).  

Yes, I disagree.

If those people who can produce original art are sulking and 
unwilling to contribute to alt.ascii-art because of requests then it 
is they themselves who are killing the "original art" postings.  

C'mon Row, that's kindergarten stuff - " It's my ball and if you 
don't play to my rules I'm taking my ball away. "

This newsgroup is alt.ascii-art not alt.ascii-original-art or 
alt.ascii-prima donnas.


> I used to collect the stuff from here, and it's got to the point 
> now where I hardly save anything. 

I have to agree that that is rather sad to hear. At the same time it 
also is not very charitable reflection on all the stuff that has 
been and continues to be posted here. It is not by any means rubbish 
and many others have praised the content of alt.ascii-art.  

If you have not been earning admiration and accolades it may be that 
you have not posted much for some time, whether by design or 
circumstance I cannot know.


> I personally would be *very* happy to start afresh on a new group 
> where requests did not eat at 90% of the postings.  

That is obvious but not very helpful to the rest of us. Come to 
think of it I have never seen you answer a request. Why do you leave 
it all to other folks ?


> Your quite free to stick around a.a-a and have it as a request for 
> ascii pictures.

That's big of you to grant me that freedom.


OTHER MATTERS:

> But perhaps it's a little bit too much trying to actively stop 
> r.a.a simply because you like a.a-a as it is. Sure, vote a NO if 
> thats what you wish, but many of your negative comments here are 
> badly uninformed.  

And what about all your negative comments about this newsgroup 
alt.ascii-art ?  Are they justified and superbly informed ?
Not in my opinion.

Is it also a concession to be allowed a NO vote ? - the number of 
times I have been asked to vote yes or not vote NO is astounding - 
and I have seen the same thing happen to other people. It is a 
wonder that a NO vote is even being permitted on this issue.


> Just think, if r.a.a *did* pass, then you could have the best of 
> both worlds - an unmoderated group for endless requests and 
> reports, and a moderated group devoted to ascii art itself.  

I think that sort of attitude is simply unworthy of you and really 
quite insulting to other folks who may not equal your artistic 
talent. It is very sad that that is how you see things, but that's 
the way of it I guess.


> Just a quick word about the moderation. It would be practically 
> invisable to the regular users, and would *only* filter things 
> which the majority of subscribers dont want to see. 

You don't really believe all that do you ?


> Nothing fairer than that.  

As a "Fair Dinkum Aussie" you have a strange concept of fairness.


> PS. No flame intended. Just trying to clear up some things.

No flame taken. You have every right to put express your views - 
make the most of it in this free unmoderated newsgroup  :-) :-)


Bye,

Original message headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit
X-Google-Thread: fb118,c675cd1e60f39a88,start
X-Google-Attributes: gidfb118,public
X-Google-Thread: f9437,c675cd1e60f39a88,start
X-Google-Attributes: gidf9437,public
X-Google-Thread: 110f55,c675cd1e60f39a88,start
X-Google-Attributes: gid110f55,public
X-Google-Thread: f996b,c675cd1e60f39a88,start
X-Google-Attributes: gidf996b,public
X-Google-ArrivalTime: 1994-05-22 22:26:02 PST
Path: bga.com!news.sprintlink.net!get.hooked.net!decwrl!decwrl!waikato!canterbury.ac.nz!equinox.gen.nz!equinox!Colin_Douthwaite
Subject: VOTING: rec.arts.ascii (MODERATED)
Newsgroups: alt.ascii-art,alt.binaries.pictures.ascii,alt.binaries.pictures.d,news.groups
X-Newsreader: TIN [version 1.2 PL3]
From: Col...@equinox.gen.nz (Colin Douthwaite)
Message-ID: <Col...@equinox.gen.nz>
Date: Mon, 23 May 94 15:58:29 +1200
Organization: Equinox Networks
Lines: 191
Xref: bga.com alt.ascii-art:8224 alt.binaries.pictures.ascii:556 alt.binaries.pictures.d:2665 news.groups:14861
About this message. This message was posted publicly to the newsgroup alt.ascii-art in 1994 and is mirrored here unchanged as part of the Historic Archives – only email addresses are masked. The artwork and text belong to their original authors: if you copy a piece, keep the artist's initials or signature intact and credit them where you can. Are you the author? Contact us to get your posts attributed, connected to your artist profile, or removed.

Report this message

Help us keep the archive clean and accurate. Reports are reviewed by a person – nothing is changed automatically.

Help classify this post